The collar is the first thing anyone reads on a shirt, which is why shirts are sized by it, named by it, and occasionally ruined by it. We sat down with a bespoke shirtmaker to work through the whole subject: collar shapes, proportion, pins and tabs, construction, and the cuffs waiting quietly at the other end of the sleeve.

Enter our prize draw to win a tie and pocket square of your choice plus a personal consultation with Chris Modoo

---

First impressions

Why the Shirt Collar Matters More Than the Shirt

Shirts are sized by their collars and, more tellingly, defined by them. Nobody describes a shirt by its side seams. You talk about cutaways, button-downs, wing collars, and only then, if at all, about fabric or colour. There is a logic to this. The collar is the part of the shirt that frames your face, the part that sits at eye level in every conversation you will ever have while wearing it. It is where the shirt meets the tie, where the shirt meets the jacket, and where the shirt meets the person opposite you. Everything else is drapery.

Which makes it faintly odd that most men give the collar less thought than they give their socks. The shape you choose changes how a tie knot sits, how a jacket frames your face, and whether an open neck looks relaxed or merely collapsed. It is also, as our shirtmaker guest was quick to point out, one of the few areas of dress where the received wisdom is mostly wrong and the useful wisdom is mostly about proportion. So let us take the collar seriously for a few minutes. It has been taking you seriously for years.

---

The starting point

What Is a Semi-Spread Collar and Why It Suits Almost Everyone

If collars have a sensible centre ground, this is it. The semi-spread sits between the forward point of the classic English collar and the swept-back extremity of the Italian cutaway. American magazines sometimes call it the English spread, because of its long association with Jermyn Street, which tells you something about how thoroughly it has been adopted as the default of good dressing. Medium in spread, medium in point length, medium in height. On paper that sounds like a compromise. In practice it is the most commercially useful collar ever devised, precisely because it refuses to make a scene.

Consider what it will tolerate. A four-in-hand knot sits happily within it. So does a half Windsor, and a full Windsor at a push, which means it works with everything from a slim knitted tie to a generously bladed printed silk. It survives being worn open under a sweater without collapsing into disarray, which very few collar shapes manage. And because it is neither extreme in one direction nor the other, it flatters most necks, most jackets, and most occasions from the boardroom to the wedding marquee.

There is one thing it will never do, and that is announce itself. If you commission a bespoke shirt and want the room to know it, the semi-spread will keep your secret indefinitely. That is either its great weakness or its great virtue, depending on the sort of man you are. We would gently suggest it is the latter. The collar that draws no attention to itself leaves all the attention for the tie, and a tie with real texture, a handmade silk or wool tie with some life in the weave, repays that attention handsomely.

---

Proportion, not face shape

How to Choose a Shirt Collar for Your Build

You will find no shortage of guides insisting that round faces need pointed collars and long faces need spread ones, as if the collar were a piece of corrective architecture. Our shirtmaker does not buy the face shape theory, and neither do we. What matters is proportion, and proportion is about the whole man rather than the geometry of his jaw.

The principle is simple. A tall man, or a man with a long neck, wants a bigger collar: deeper in the band, longer in the points, so that it balances the frame rather than sitting on it like an afterthought. A smaller man, or a man whose neck is shorter, wants the opposite. Put a towering collar on a compact frame and the effect drifts towards fancy dress. The same logic, incidentally, runs right through tailoring: wider lapels call for longer pocket flaps, deeper collars call for deeper cuffs. Balance is the whole game.

There is one physical consideration worth taking seriously, and that concerns the jowl. If your face carries a little more of itself these days, resist the instinct to hide behind a deep collar. A tall collar will cut into the jowl, ride up into the face, and be genuinely uncomfortable by mid-morning. Go smaller instead. The collar should sit beneath the line of the face, quietly, doing its job. This is exactly the sort of adjustment a bespoke shirtmaker makes as a matter of course, and exactly the sort of thing ready-to-wear cannot do for you, which is why knowing the principle matters. When the collar is fixed, choose the shirt around the collar that fits, and let the tie do the talking.

---

The forward point

Point Collars, Pin Collars and Tab Collars Explained

Bring the points of a collar closer together and you have a point collar, a style with a long and occasionally notorious history. The versions with real length in the points belong to the 1970s and, before that, to the 1930s and 40s, when collars were shorter, sharper and worn proudly outside the jacket. A modern refinement is a gentle curve on the outside edge, which originally existed to let the collar sit over the collarbone without breaking. As jackets have moved to lower button stances, that curve has straightened out in many cuts, because a straighter run gives the collar the leverage to tuck neatly under the lapel. A small detail, and like most small details in shirtmaking, entirely functional.

The point collar's great party trick is the pin. There are three ways to do it. A collar bar passes through eyelet holes made in the collar, like a very refined nut and bolt. A safety-pin style pierces the fabric itself, which works but leaves you making holes in your own shirt, an activity we cannot in good conscience recommend. And a collar clip grips both edges without piercing anything, which does the least damage and, crucially, leaves you free to wear the shirt without it. The effect in every case is the same: the points are drawn in behind the tie, the knot is pushed forward, and the whole arrangement takes on a three-dimensional quality that flat collars simply cannot produce. Watch any well-dressed villain in a 1990 gangster picture and you will see long point collars crying out for exactly this treatment.

The tab collar achieves the same lift by different means, with a small fabric tab fastening behind the knot. It is less decorative than a pin and considerably harder to wear without a tie, so consider it a committed choice. Both styles favour a tie with a modest, dense knot, which is where a grenadine or a knitted tie earns its keep: enough texture to reward the closer inspection the pin invites, without the bulk that would crowd the narrower points.

---

The swept-back option

The Cutaway Collar: How to Wear It With and Without a Tie

The cutaway is usually described as an Italian style, which is true in the way most Italian menswear stories are true: it began as a British idea, the Italians borrowed it and made it more extreme, and everyone agreed the result was more fun. Sweep the points back far enough and you begin to see the band of the tie either side of the knot, which some regard as a mark of confident dressing and others regard as untidy. It is a style with opinions attached, in other words, and the further back the points go, the louder the opinions become.

Its formal credentials are impeccable. The cutaway descends from the starched, detachable collar worn with morning dress, which is why you still see it doing serious work at weddings and in the smarter corners of the West End. Starched collars themselves are enjoying a quiet resurgence, in the way that vest slips have gone from obscure to almost normal within twenty years, though anyone tempted should know the maintenance is real: molten starch, specialist laundering after every wear, and considerable shrinkage. Beautiful, and demanding. Wing collars for white tie remain the one place starch is non-negotiable, because an unstarched wing collar simply looks defeated.

The cutaway's less advertised talent is at the other end of the formality scale entirely. Because the points are short and swept back, the collar tends to stand up around the neck like a barrel rather than draping downward, which makes it one of the best collars to wear open. In linen or a soft cotton it is a genuinely elegant smart casual shirt, at ease under an unstructured jacket with a pocket square doing the decorative work the tie has been excused from. One collar, two lives, both of them lived well.

---

Under the surface

Collar Construction: Fused Linings, Loose Linings and Collar Stays

Two collars can share an identical shape and behave like entirely different garments, and the difference lives inside. A loose lining, the traditional West End construction, floats free between the layers of cotton. It gives the collar substance and a certain amount of life, a willingness to move that reads as handmade because it is. A fused lining is bonded to the fabric, producing something smoother, cleaner and lighter. Done well on proper machinery, modern fusing is respectable and durable. Done badly, it bubbles, and once a fused collar has bubbled it stays bubbled, in exactly the way a fused suit chest delaminates at the dry cleaner and never recovers. The blunt arithmetic our shirtmaker offered is worth remembering: a loose-lined collar lasts until the cotton wears out, a fused collar lasts until the glue does.

Then there are collar stays, the small stiffeners that slide into slots under the points, and here we can be usefully brief. If your collar looks messy, wavy, or possessed of an unwanted life of its own, the overwhelming likelihood is that the stays are missing. Put them in and the collar becomes clean and composed at a stroke. They were once a quiet signifier of a better made shirt, in the same category as a split yoke or proper tails, and they remain the cheapest improvement available in all of shirting. The only time to leave them out is when you actively want a soft, casual collar with some flop in it, in which case flop away, deliberately.

---

The open collar

The Best Shirt Collars to Wear Without a Tie

Here is the uncomfortable truth every shirtmaker knows and few customers want to hear: a shirt is designed to be buttoned up and worn with a tie. Undo the button and remove the tie and you are asking a structure built to stand upright to relax gracefully instead, and structures are rarely good at that. Left to its own devices, an open collar collapses. The question is whether it collapses with style.

There are tricks. Cutting the collar smaller makes it sit higher and more upright. Bringing the points closer to the band creates that barrel effect around the neck, the same principle that makes the open cutaway work. A soft, unlined collar with a generous tie space and weight in the points can be persuaded to flop in a deliberately louche way rather than an accidental one. All of this is available to the man commissioning his shirts. For everyone else, there is the button-down.

The button-down is the one collar genuinely engineered for open wear, its points anchored so the collar rolls rather than collapses. Its history is worth knowing, because it explains its character. The classic American Oxford button-down is a sport shirt, generously cut with a box pleat in the back, designed to allow movement on the polo field long before stretch fabrics existed. Americans consequently regard it as conservative and traditional. The British regard it as sporty and casual. Both are right, which is rather the charm. As for the perfect collar roll, that gentle curve the enthusiasts photograph and argue about online, know that it is the bane of the people who make shirts, since it depends on the button sitting in exactly the right spot, every time. Somewhere a shirtmaker is squinting at a button placement right now, on your behalf.

---

Down to the wrist

Double Cuffs vs Button Cuffs: Which to Choose and When

The double cuff folds back on itself to create two layers, fastens with a cufflink, and remains the correct answer for formal business and smart occasions. Part of its appeal is simple manners: dressing to meet the occasion, making the extra effort, and taking one of the few opportunities a man has to wear a small piece of jewellery. Part of it is architectural. A double cuff fills the sleeve of a jacket properly, sitting into it with a substance that a plain cuff never quite achieves. Its rarer cousin, the single link cuff, is a single layer fastened with links, reserved for white tie, where heavily starched cotton cannot be folded back and looks all the cleaner for it. If your diary runs to occasions like that, our black tie collection covers the neckwear side of the equation.

For everything else there is the button cuff, known in England as exactly that and in America as the barrel cuff. The default of Jermyn Street was long the two-button version with a rounded edge, and the round is more than decoration. A square corner folds a good deal of fabric into a point, and every pass of the iron over that point softens and eventually wears it. A smooth curve carries less bulk and lasts longer, while also being harder to sew, which is why a well-executed rounded cuff quietly signals a well made shirt. Beyond that the variations are matters of taste: mitred edges, deeper cuffs, an unfastened second button to let a watch breathe. On watches, the only firm rule is that the cuff should sit over the watch rather than snag on it. And yes, cuffs with a window to display the watch inside do exist. One customer of our shirtmaker ordered one, once, and never again, which tells you everything. Just because something can be done does not mean it should be.

Two further styles complete the family. The convertible cuff fastens with either a button or a cufflink, an each-way bet that sounds practical on paper and in practice pleases neither occasion fully, which is why you see so few of them in serious wardrobes. The cocktail cuff is the more interesting outlier: a turned-back cuff that fastens with buttons rather than links, giving you the substance of a double cuff without the jewellery, and carrying a faint whiff of a certain fictional naval commander for those who notice such things. On monograms, the convention is initials on the edge of the cuff, though the sleeve placket is a quieter and arguably more elegant home for them. Keep the thread within a tone of the shirt fabric and the effect stays where it belongs, which is just short of visible.

The proportion principle from the collar applies at the wrist too. If you favour a deeper, longer collar, a deeper cuff keeps the shirt in balance, in the same way wide lapels ask for longer pocket flaps. And whatever the cuff, let it show. Around half an inch beyond the jacket sleeve is the classic measure, enough to prove the shirt is there and the sleeves were cut with intention. The shirt is a single composition. The collar and cuffs are simply where it chooses to make its arguments.

---

Bringing it together

How to Match Your Collar, Tie and Cuffs

If all of this has left you with a decision to make, let it be this one. Choose the collar for your proportions, choose the cuff for the occasion, and choose the tie for the collar. A semi-spread takes almost any knot you own. A point or pin collar wants something narrower and denser, a grenadine or a knitted tie that rewards the closer framing. A cutaway can carry a fuller knot and a bolder pattern, and worn open it hands the decorative duties to a silk pocket square instead. None of this is complicated. It simply asks for a moment's attention, which is, after all, the whole point of dressing well.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Your Questions Answered

---

To view the full collection click on the button below.